TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
Morgan Stanley Research Report Interpretation: AI ROIC Debate Remains Core Focus, Internet Valuation at Historical Lows but Divergence Unresolved

Morgan Stanley Research Report Interpretation: AI ROIC Debate Remains Core Focus, Internet Valuation at Historical Lows but Divergence Unresolved

2026.08.19
Share
Morgan Stanley believes the outcome of the AI ROIC debate will determine whether valuations trend toward repair or further compression; until then, the sector is likely to remain range-bound.

Written by: Rita

The Internet sector fell 1% overall last week, with Amazon and Google down 4% and 2% respectively, leading the broader market decline.

In its Internet industry weekly report released on August 18, Morgan Stanley pointed out that the AI ROIC debate remains the core focus of market attention.

The current valuation levels of the three Internet giants—Amazon, Google, and Meta—are 20 times, 17 times, and 19 times their 2026 earnings per share respectively, representing discounts of 7% to 14% compared to their respective five-year averages.

However, the valuation discount has not yet translated into sustained buying, and there remains a fundamental divergence in the market regarding the return on AI capital expenditures.

Divergent Performance in Internet Sector, E-commerce Leads Decline

The Internet sector overall underperformed the broader market last week. The S&P 500 rose 0.4%, Nasdaq rose 0.1%, while the Internet sector overall fell 1%.

E-commerce was the weakest sub-sector, with a market-cap weighted average decline of 4.4%, where Amazon's 4.3% drop was the main drag.

Amazon's stock price has remained under pressure following its Q2 earnings report, as the market continues to digest concerns regarding the scale of its AI capital expenditures.

The digital advertising sector fell 1.8%, led by Google.

The travel and sharing economy sectors rose 1.6% and 0.7% respectively, being the only sub-sectors to achieve positive returns.

In terms of monthly performance, the divergence within the Internet sector is even more pronounced.

AppLovin fell 29.7% within a month, Roblox fell 29.8%, and Playtika fell 36.3%.

Morgan Stanley pointed out that these companies were previously seen as potential targets for "AI disruption," and the market is repricing their long-term value.

Meanwhile, ABNB rose 25.6%, EXPE rose 24.9%, and the strong performance of the travel sector reflects market confidence in consumer resilience.

Valuations at Lows, Buying Consensus Yet to Form

The valuations of the three Internet giants have entered historical low ranges.

Amazon's NTM EV/EBITDA is 11.5 times, a 10% discount to the two-year average and a 12% discount to the three-year average.

Google is at 15.3 times, a 9% premium to the two-year average and a 14% premium to the three-year average, making it the relatively most expensive of the three.

Meta is at 9.4 times, a 24% discount to the two-year average and a 22% discount to the three-year average, representing the largest discount.

From a longer-term perspective, the Internet sector's overall NTM EV/EBITDA is at a 7% discount to the five-year average and a 14% discount to the ten-year average, standing at historical lows.

However, NTM EV/Sales is at a 19% premium to the five-year average and a 21% premium to the ten-year average, indicating that the market's pricing of revenue remains higher than historical averages, but the valuation of profitability has been significantly compressed.

The divergence between revenue valuation and earnings valuation reflects high uncertainty in the market regarding whether AI investments can be converted into profits.

Morgan Stanley believes that the AI ROIC debate is the key variable.

If market confidence in the return on AI capital expenditures recovers, valuations may repair from current lows; conversely, if AI spending continues to erode profit margins, valuations may compress further.

After SBC Adjustment, Valuations Not as Cheap as They Appear

Morgan Stanley also analyzed the impact of Stock-Based Compensation (SBC) on valuations; if SBC is treated as a cash expenditure rather than a non-cash item, the true valuation level of the Internet sector will be significantly pushed higher.

The median EV/EBITDA of the digital media sector will rise by about 36%, the e-commerce sector by about 30%, the gaming sector by about 15%, and the travel/sharing economy/prop-tech sector by about 44%.

Valuation levels after SBC adjustment are significantly higher than surface numbers.

Morgan Stanley believes that current low valuations are distorted to some extent by the accounting treatment of SBC.

This perspective is crucial for understanding the true valuations of Internet companies.

Many Internet companies heavily use stock-based compensation as part of employee remuneration; on the surface EBITDA looks high, but actual cash costs may be higher.

If calculated on a cash basis, current valuations are not as cheap as they appear on the surface.

The Internet sector is currently in an awkward position: valuations are at historical lows, but the AI ROIC debate remains unresolved, and the market has not reached a consensus on the return on AI capital expenditures.

Morgan Stanley believes that the outcome of the AI ROIC debate will determine whether valuations move towards repair or further compression; before then, the sector is likely to maintain range-bound oscillation.

Disclaimer

This article is a compilation and interpretation by TechFlow Research of a third-party broker research report (Morgan Stanley, August 18, 2026), combined with a compilation of public market information.

The ratings, target prices, earnings forecasts, and related judgments cited in the text are the views of the broker's analysts, represent only the position of their affiliated institution, do not represent the views of TechFlow Research, and do not constitute any investment advice.

The market involves risks, decisions must be independent. This article should not be used as a basis for buying or selling any securities.