
Foreign Media Slams Zuckerberg's 6,500-Word AI Manifesto: Those Who Can't Win Start Questioning the Race Itself
Author: Claude, TechFlow
TechFlow Editor's Note: On Monday, Zuckerberg released a 6,500-word AI manifesto titled "The Future Is for Everyone," arguing extensively that "AI power cannot be concentrated in the hands of a few companies." Wired's criticism was blunt: the whole piece is marketing, with almost no substance. Behind the emptiness lies a more awkward reality: Meta spent billions of dollars chasing closed-source competitors but has yet to produce results that catch up.
On August 10, Meta CEO Zuckerberg published a long article titled "The Future Is for Everyone," approximately 6,500 words in total, an expanded version of his previous Wall Street Journal column. Three days later, Wired broke down this manifesto paragraph by paragraph on its podcast Uncanny Valley, with the conclusion written in the title: 6,500 Words, Almost Nothing Said.
Wired's Takedown Was Direct: "This Is Marketing, Not Thought"
Executive Editor Brian Barrett categorized this type of article into the unfortunate genre of "Tech CEO Philosophical Manifestos," which both Sam Altman and Dario Amodei have written, but the essence of Zuckerberg's piece is a "marketing manifesto," with the core message being nothing more than one sentence: "Don't worry everyone, AI is good, and it will make your life better." Director of Politics and Science Leah Feiger was even briefer in her evaluation after reading through: "A bunch of empty talk."
Zoë Schiffer pointed out the most representative paragraph of the manifesto: Zuckerberg used "AI agents generating personalized recipes so he can bake with his daughter" to depict the future of AI. Her question was, why is a personalized cookie recipe needed? Such examples fundamentally avoid the fact that these tools are powerful and dangerous, and this is precisely during the "Summer of Rogue AI Agents," among the agents that went wrong include Meta's own products. Barrett's wording was harsher: the manifesto "almost radically ignored all potential negative impacts."
Boiling Down 6,500 Words, Actually Just One Sentence
The core argument of the manifesto is that concentrating AI power in the hands of a few institutions is dangerous, and this power must be dispersed through widely open model access. Zuckerberg wrote: "Historically, expecting an absolute power to benevolently provide for humanity under a sufficiently enlightened state has never brought safe or positive results."
This passage did not name names, but the target was clear: OpenAI and Anthropic, which implement strict controls on private models. Schiffer added the writing motivation: Zuckerberg previously told reporter Alex Heath that Meta is about to start releasing superintelligent models, and he hopes the world understands his philosophy first. In other words, this manifesto is not a reflection written for the public, but public opinion groundwork before the new model release.
The Things the Manifesto Didn't Mention Are Meta's Real Problems
Emptiness is not negligence; emptiness covers up Meta's current predicament. The company's long-term bet on the open-source route, using open-weight models to hedge against OpenAI and Anthropic's closed-source profitability, received Wired's evaluation as "this move didn't work." Subsequently, Meta spent billions of dollars frantically poaching talent to build a superintelligence lab, staging that sky-high salary talent war with OpenAI last summer, but the lab has yet to produce results catching up with top competitors. A few months ago, Meta laid off a large number of people from this team.
On the same day the manifesto was released, Meta also released a brand new open-weight system named Muse Glimmer. Open source, catch up, layoff, open source again, the host described it as "strategy bumping around everywhere, turning constantly." Feiger's interpretation was the most ruthless: this "Philosophy 101" level argument is essentially sour grapes for not being invited to the big kids' sandbox game, "It's like you can't win a game, so you say, actually we shouldn't have competed at all."
Timing of Release More Revealing Than Content
Less than a week before the manifesto was released, Meta was just ordered by the court to pay $567 million because it failed to adequately protect children's online safety and mental health. The questions raised in the program were therefore particularly sharp: Why should we believe Meta can handle AI's impact on society? A more subtle contrast is, even the Trump White House, which has consistently opposed AI regulation, has already issued policy responses due to national security threats, while Zuckerberg is still depicting a relaxed scene of "AI teaching your child to cook."
The real readers of this type of CEO manifesto are never the public, but regulators in Washington and Wall Street. Emptiness may not be a mistake but a strategy: the less said, the fewer commitments, the greater room for maneuver. But an experiment by the program team pierced through everything. They used the AI detection tool Pangram to test this 6,500-word manifesto, the result was human-written. Barrett's comment could serve as this manifesto's epitaph: "For Zuckerberg, AI is good enough to write cookie recipes for his daughter, but not good enough to write a manifesto for him."













