
Pawnbroker Ledger
Written by: Thejaswini M A
Compiled by: Block unicorn
All lenders in the world are doing one of two things: either getting to know your identity, or seizing your assets.
The first job is massive and costly. It builds credit bureaus, credit scoring companies, underwriting departments, collection agencies, and courts to enforce judgments. The consequences of default follow you for years. Trillions of dollars in infrastructure exist to allow banks to lend money to strangers and have a rough idea of whether that money can be recovered.
The second job requires a set of scales, nothing more.
Securities lenders, aka margin clerks, price the collateral and then sleep soundly. This is the oldest form of lending, and it works perfectly. It never grew large because a system where you must own something before you can borrow something mainly serves those who don't need it.
Crypto lending plays the second most important role in the lending field, which is security. When people think of crypto, they panic, thinking first of negative events like the Sam Bankman-Fried incident. So, choosing a safer lending method is a good thing for us.
In the crypto field, to borrow one thousand dollars, you first need to have one thousand five hundred dollars.
This product is only for people who already have funds. For traders who want to use leverage but don't want to sell their positions, it works very well, and this itself is a real business. As for others, our proposal is to prove you don't need it, and then we give it to you. This is fair.
In the traditional financial system, credit drives economic growth. Banks lend money to a baker to buy an oven based on his future ability to sell bread. Banks trust borrowers, thereby creating new economic value. This model works because people who need loans, by definition, are those short of funds.
Today I want to show you who is trying to do the first type of work on-chain, and what ultimately happened to them.
In the United States, the crypto market size is as high as $5.14 trillion. Yet the crypto lending market size is nearly zero. There are not many factors hindering crypto development:
Identity. Unfortunately, wallets are not people after all. I can create ten thousand wallets now just by paying Gas fees. If lenders cannot distinguish whether the address coming to borrow today is the same person as the borrower who defaulted last year, then the credit system built on reputation will collapse on the first day someone tries to attack it.
Pricing. Even if the identity verification problem is solved, lenders need a way to charge different interest rates to different borrowers: some borrowers are charged 9%, some 29%. This requires historical records, which in turn requires the involvement of credit agencies. On-chain data can show a wallet's activity in DeFi, but you cannot know whether this person kept their job, or whether they repaid previous loans on time.
Recourse. Under normal circumstances, when a borrower stops repaying, a series of consequences follow. Collection calls come in, default records are entered into credit files, and courts can even garnish wages. But if a wallet stops repaying, what can you do? Abandoning a wallet has no cost. The creditor knows neither your name nor your address, nor is there anything to seize.
The fourth point is law. Every enforcement method I just listed requires a license. Collection agencies must hold a license to operate and comply with federal regulations, including collection frequency and content. Interest rates charged by lenders are also subject to usury caps, which vary by state and product. Consumer credit is one of the most strictly regulated activities in the financial field, and conducting such business without a license is illegal.
See where this pushes everyone. We all end up going to the grave.
Goldfinch was founded in 2021 with backing from a16z and Coinbase Ventures, completely bypassing on-chain identity verification. They lend to real businesses in these markets through professional underwriters who understand emerging markets, with crypto providing the capital. Goldfinch has motorcycle taxi financing agencies in Kenya, lending agencies in Nigeria and Southeast Asia, and borrowers across 18 countries.
In October 2021, Tugende Kenya received a $5 million loan to expand its motorcycle financing business for taxi drivers. Goldfinch later discovered that $1.9 million of it was transferred to Tugende's struggling Uganda parent company, which the loan terms did not allow. Tugende defaulted in June 2023.
Another borrower, Stratos, defaulted on a $7 million credit line, and a third borrower, Lend East, defaulted on nearly $6 million. In total, the protocol watched helplessly as over $18 million in funds disappeared into the real-world risks they originally intended to solve. After issuing about $100 million in funds, Goldfinch ceased operations this June. Its token price fell by 99.8%.
Thinking carefully, these failure cases are without exception ordinary credit failures. Oil prices rose, drivers couldn't pay, contracts were breached, borrowers transferred funds they shouldn't have. The blockchain worked well; it just couldn't predict whether these funds could be recovered.
Maple is a more enlightening case because Maple is the largest unsecured crypto lending platform in history, and it did not perish. But to survive, it had to completely abandon its original mission. It realized that in the crypto field, unsecured lending based on trust and identity is too risky.
On December 5, 2022, Orthogonal Trading defaulted on eight loans totaling $36 million. This accounted for about 30% of all active loans on the protocol. Before November, Orthogonal had been telling its underwriters that its exposure on FTX was about $2.5 million. On December 3, the company admitted the actual amount was far higher. This deception immediately caused 80% of the funds in the pool with the largest exposure (the M11 USDC pool, about $31 million) to vanish. Maple admitted they might only recover $2.5 million out of the $36 million total.
Sid Powell later stated that undercollateralized loans require stricter due diligence, and Maple might shift to partial collateralization.
It marched forward all the way. Today, Maple's loan collateralization rate exceeds 140%, there have been no losses since 2023, and deposit amounts have consequently grown by over $2.2 billion. This safer option proved effective.

This leads to the question of who is trying now, because many people are trying, and they have clearly categorized themselves according to the obstacles they are attacking.
Divine Research is dedicated to tackling identity blocking. Since December 2024, the company has issued about 30,000 loans, mostly under $1,000, denominated in USD, to borrowers including teachers, fruit vendors, and anyone who can access the internet. Borrowers must verify their identity via World ID iris scan, which prevents someone from opening a second account after abandoning the first. Loan interest rates are 20% to 30%. According to the Financial Times, the default rate for the first loans is about 40%.
3Jane is dedicated to tackling pricing blocking. It obtains borrower bank data via Plaid and uses Credit Karma's VantageScore, then encapsulates both in zero-knowledge proofs to ensure no sensitive information is transmitted on-chain. Ultimately, they issue credit lines based on the results. Paradigm led its seed funding round. 3Jane currently holds about $62 million in funds and is the largest on-chain unsecured lending institution today.
Wildcat is a recourse company that does not perform any underwriting. It publishes a master loan agreement template; after borrowers and lenders sign, Wildcat no longer intervenes. Its own documents state that the company does not assess borrower creditworthiness, and once lending operations begin, it must not intervene in market operations.
Huma took a different development path, completely stopping lending to individuals. Huma Finance is considered the first PayFi network. They established a partnership with Qiro Finance, which serves as the strategic underwriting and risk monitoring partner for the Huma PayFi network.
Huma provides financing services for invoices and cross-border payment flows, where known institutions owe known amounts on known dates. The company has facilitated $2.3 billion in transactions this way.
None of these solutions enforce any terms on-chain. Divine will exclude you from the future, which is the weakest sanction of all solutions, and its 40% default rate indicates borrowers have anticipated the consequences of this sanction. 3Jane will hand documents to a US collection agency; this works because its borrowers are US citizens with legal identity and credit records, and default damages these records. Wildcat goes directly to court.
If there is no over-collateral available to seize, all viable mechanisms are forced to retreat to the old system. Once problems arise, in most cases, it is lawyer intervention that causes people to pay the price.
Note what areas those successful cases have shifted to. 3Jane's website now describes it as a credit-backed yield coin for fintech originators, offering warehouse lines of $5 million to $200 million. It purchased $8.5 million in small business receivables from a company named Slope. Huma provides financing for B2B payment processes. If payment default occurs, Huma relies on real-world factoring agreements and dispatches lawyers to enforce contracts. Both protocols have shifted to institutional lending because institutional lending can anchor debt in the traditional system, with signed agreements and corresponding jurisdiction.
Therefore, the market's next attempt is source withholding.
If your salary goes directly on-chain, lenders can receive repayment before you get the money. This is the first mechanism in the crypto field that directly touches consumer funds. This infrastructure went online this year. Deel processes $22 billion in payroll and began providing stablecoin payroll payment services to about 40,000 enterprises in the UK and EU via MoonPay this March. Rise has natively supported stablecoin payroll payments for years. Toku partnered with Aleo and Paxos to build a private version for companies that cannot publicly disclose payroll on public chains. Since these companies formally use stablecoins to pay salaries, the infrastructure for "source deduction" is finally in place.
But the problem remains. Deel pays funds to non-custodial wallets—employees' wallets, employees' private keys. Once funds arrive there, lenders can no longer have any rights over them, nor can they access funds from them. Interception must occur upstream of the Web2 payroll file. But if service providers like Deel allow crypto protocols to access their systems, they suddenly become debt collection companies or credit service providers.
As we pointed out in the obstacles section, "law" strictly regulates wage garnishment and salary deduction. Currently, no payroll service providers, including Rise, Bitwage, and Deel, provide automatic loan deduction or wage garnishment functions for Web3 lending protocols.
Crypto can transfer funds to anyone on earth in seconds. Since the system guarantees irreversible settlement, it is essentially unable to enforce fund return. Every time someone tries to recover funds, they rely on traditional means, such as courts, collection agencies, credit agencies, or bosses.
Actually, source withholding is not a new technology.
In the 19th century, British and American employers paid wages in the form of company vouchers, which could be redeemed at company stores at prices set by the company. Workers' wages never truly became currency disposable by the employers. Parliament passed the "Truck Acts" precisely to stop this practice, requiring wages to be paid in national currency. The mechanism lies in the fact that employers controlled both the wages and where the wages went.
Source withholding is also how the 401k plan works. Student loan garnishment, child support, and all wage savings plans are the same. These are not exploitation at all.
Brazil has implemented a source withholding system for twenty years, the so-called "consignado," deducting installment payments directly from wages. The average wage loan interest rate is 28%, while unsecured loan interest rates are as high as 146%. But this system relies entirely on a strict legal framework, such as employer contracts, wage caps, and labor courts. Crypto also needs such a system, but the blockchain itself cannot read or execute the traditional legal mechanisms required to run this system.
The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) established the "Credit Practices Rule" in 1984, one of the six prohibited behaviors of which is wage assignment. Creditors can no longer include clauses in consumer loan contracts that transfer borrower wages directly to the lender. Creditors can use wage deduction plans, where consumers authorize a series of deductions to pay each installment. But creditors cannot conduct wage assignments that borrowers cannot revoke.
Therefore, deductions are allowed as a payment method, but not as a collection method.
The US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) elaborated on its reasoning. The FTC found that wage garnishment forces people to give up legal defenses, because borrowers would rather repay their disputed debts than have creditors contact their employers about the matter. Some people worry about losing their jobs because of this. Due to the lack of legal enforcement, crypto wage deductions rely on the borrower's voluntary consent, but this does not solve any problems, because defaulting borrowers can easily revoke this consent.
The reason Brazil's model works is that the law locks the deduction amount and limits wage loss, thereby depriving borrowers of the ability to cancel the loan.
This is why these protocols strategically choose jurisdictions. Divine Research operates overseas, while 3Jane relies on US courts and credit agencies. They each choose to operate in jurisdictions that can provide the required legal effectiveness in the real world to ensure funds can be recovered.
So, what conditions need to be met for crypto to obtain consumer credit?
Lenders need to confirm that multiple electronic wallets belong to the same person; if everyone agrees to accept scanning, biometric technology can solve this problem. It also needs a legally regulated credit agency to track individual repayment records across different protocols. Additionally, it needs a way to force users to continue repaying after canceling repayment. Consumer protection laws will never allow anonymous software to have such great influence over users' actual income.
Aave has been running for six years but has never known any user's name. Blockchain cannot resort to law and courts. Therefore, we can only wait.















