TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
Should we be concerned about a yen carry trade reversal?

Should we be concerned about a yen carry trade reversal?

2026.09.21
Share
If the US economy weakens more than expected, the asset side will be the trigger for a mass unwind of carry trades.

Authors: Wu Shuo, Lin Yan, Wallstreetcn

The Bank of Japan delivered its scheduled interest rate hike in September, albeit with a scale falling short of the market's prior aggressive expectations, giving markets a brief moment to catch their breath. Previously, the yen's rapid appreciation, combined with a flurry of hawkish signals from BOJ officials, led the market to once again recall the 2024 carry trade reversal—when global assets faced broad sell-offs, casting a long shadow over markets and instilling lingering caution regarding this BOJ tightening move.

However, the Bank of Japan was not as hawkish as previously expected by the market. Although Kazuo Ueda did not rule out consecutive rate hikes at the post-meeting press conference, the exact pace of tightening remains ambiguous. Combined with a benign external environment (steady US August non-farm payrolls, declining oil prices), multiple factors jointly limited the impact of this rate hike on global markets. Asia-Pacific stock markets surged across the board, and the yen weakened further after the hike was implemented.

Nevertheless, market concerns have not been entirely alleviated. As the BOJ's rate hike cycle continues, yen funding costs are rising, gradually diminishing the yen's appeal as a funding currency for global carry trades. However, we believe the risk of a sudden, concentrated reversal of yen-funded carry trades has decreased in the short term. Capital is more likely to flow back slowly, keeping overall spillover impacts manageable.

Fundamentally, the yen carry trade is driven by the interplay of three key components: the funding leg, the exchange rate leg, and the asset leg. On the funding leg, low-interest yen are borrowed, with financing costs determined by the BOJ's policy rate. On the exchange rate leg, the borrowed yen are converted into USD, where exchange rate fluctuations directly impact principal conversion gains/losses. On the asset leg, USD is used to allocate to high-yield assets such as US Treasuries and equities, earning yield differentials and capital gains.

Therefore, a large-scale, stampede-style unwinding of carry trades typically requires the resonance of three conditions: continued BOJ rate hikes pushing up yen funding costs; rapid and significant yen appreciation causing FX losses; and a decline in USD asset prices compressing profit margins.

Currently, while certain marginal changes have emerged across the three legs, the catalytic conditions triggering a full-scale, stampede-style unwinding have not yet materialized:

On the funding leg, although the BOJ has begun hiking rates, its overall stance remains cautious, and it is unlikely to quickly raise yen funding costs. Fundamental constraints and fiscal limitations within Japan are challenges the BOJ cannot ignore, meaning it lacks the foundation for rapid and substantial rate hikes (a point particularly clear when compared to the United States).

Meanwhile, the core profit of carry positions stems from the US-Japan yield spread. Although the funding appeal of the yen is waning, the spread remains elevated (the 10-year spread still stands at around 200 bps), which will not rapidly erode the profitability of carry trades in the short term. Traders still have time to adjust leverage and gradually reduce positions, making it difficult for a concentrated, passive unwinding to occur.

On the exchange rate leg, what matters is not just the absolute level of the yen, but crucially, the pace of its appreciation. Only a rapid short-term surge in the yen can quickly generate unrealized FX losses, forcing traders to close positions collectively. If the yen strengthens gradually, the market has ample time to adjust positions, reducing the likelihood of a stampede.

The current pace of yen appreciation has slowed down: partly due to the BOJ's likely gradual hike pace amid fundamental constraints; and partly because this round of BOJ tightening resonates with the Federal Reserve's policy cycle, which to some extent caps the narrowing of the US-Japan yield differential, curbing the yen's one-way rapid appreciation momentum.

On the asset leg, performance hinges primarily on global risk appetite and the returns of USD-denominated assets. Carry trade funds ultimately flow into USD assets such as US Treasuries and equities, making this the profit source of carry trades. Once US equities face sharp pullbacks and US Treasury yields drop rapidly, asset returns will shrink or even turn into losses. Coupled with rising yen funding costs and FX losses from a strengthening yen, these triple pressures can easily trigger large-scale position unwinds.

Currently, USD high-yield assets like US equities generally maintain resilience. The macroeconomic environment and AI terminal demand have not yet seen systemic deterioration. Asset-side returns remain sufficient to cover yen funding and FX costs, and funds lack a strong catalyst for a concentrated exit.

In summary, at present, the BOJ's rate hike pace is relatively cautious, the yen lacks the basis for a one-sided sharp rally, and overseas asset legs show no signs of systematic crashes. Therefore, it is difficult to replicate the severe carry trade unwind shock seen in 2024 in the short term.

Additionally, the crowdedness of yen short trades has significantly decreased since US-Japan joint intervention. Yen shorts have substantially covered their positions. As of the week ending September 15, CME non-commercial yen short positions had dropped by approximately 56% from their late July peaks, while long positions surged by 135%. Since September, net long holdings have also moved out of negative territory. Given that some yen shorts have already covered early, the risk of subsequent rapid covering triggering a concentrated unwinding of carry trades remains relatively manageable.

Monitoring whether carry trades will experience a concentrated reversal going forward requires close tracking of: whether the BOJ's rate hike pace and magnitude accelerate beyond expectations, and the speed and slope of the yen's short-term appreciation. However, the most critical factor is that asset-side risks remain the core catalyst triggering concentrated carry trade unwinds.

We can actually draw lessons from the 2024 carry trade reversal on this point. At that time, the market similarly faced an environment of sharply appreciating yen and BOJ rate hikes. However, the final blow that broke carry positions came from asset-side shocks caused by a correction in global risk assets. Initially in 2024, straightforward rises in yen rates and yen appreciation only triggered gradual position adjustments. It wasn't until August, when rising US unemployment triggered the Sahm Rule, boosted recession expectations, that systemic global asset sell-offs finally occurred, accelerating the concentrated unwinding of carry trades and the yen's appreciation trend.

Therefore, greater attention should be paid to tail risks emerging on the US asset side, which could accelerate the reversal of carry trades. Key areas to monitor include potentially triggering factors such as continued US economic weakness exceeding expectations, escalating geopolitical tensions, growing divergence in the AI sector, and violent volatility in the US Treasury market, which may increase the risk of concentrated short-term carry trade unwinds.