TechFlow Logo
Login/ Sign up
ETH Gas
Gwei
Fear
gas
a16z Crypto: Marc Andreessen and Chris Dixon Explain Why the CLARITY Act Is Urgent

a16z Crypto: Marc Andreessen and Chris Dixon Explain Why the CLARITY Act Is Urgent

2026.08.07
Share
The passage of the bill will provide enterprises with a long-term stable operating framework, promoting compliant development in the crypto industry.

Author:a16z crypto

Compiled by: Jiahuan, ChainCatcher

Crypto assets are no longer a niche market. Stablecoins carry trillions of dollars in transactions annually, and major banks and payment companies are developing on-chain businesses. However, U.S. federal rules regulating these activities remain incomplete.

The CLARITY Act is designed to address this issue. The bill proposes establishing a federal regulatory framework for the crypto market, dividing responsibilities between the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), requiring project parties to disclose information and restrict insider behavior, while bringing intermediaries such as trading platforms into a regulatory system similar to traditional financial markets. If the bill passes, blockchain systems will gain clear basic rules, ending the state of uncertainty that has hindered innovation and exposed consumers to risk for years.

This article is a Q&A piece compiled and published by a16z crypto based on a recent video conversation. The guests were a16z co-founder Marc Andreessen and a16z crypto founder Chris Dixon.

The two discussed why the crypto industry needs clear and lasting rules now, how the CLARITY Act will protect consumers, and why regulatory ambiguity benefits violators. The conversation also covered illegal financial activities, privacy, and government ethics; what happens if the bill fails to pass; why this matters for U.S. technological leadership; and why maintaining the status quo might be the biggest risk.

Why Does the Crypto Industry Need Rules Now?

Since the release of the Bitcoin whitepaper, the crypto industry has changed significantly. Initially used mainly by amateur players and tech enthusiasts, it has now developed into an industry with gradually maturing infrastructure and increasing institutional participation.

This technology has grown into an industry. Stablecoins process trillions of dollars in transactions annually, comparable in volume to the Visa network. Large financial institutions such as banks, asset management companies, card networks, and fintech companies are developing products around stablecoins, tokenized stocks, tokenized deposits, and other digital assets. Underlying networks have also become faster and cheaper: transactions that previously cost several dollars can now be settled in less than a second on widely used blockchains, at a cost of less than one cent.

For various reasons, U.S. regulation of crypto assets has been split into two parts: stablecoins, and the market beyond stablecoins. The GENIUS Act, effective July 2025, established a federal framework for stablecoins, but the blockchain networks and trading markets on which stablecoins rely still lack a complete federal regulatory system. This is like regulating only mobile phones while leaving communication base stations in a legal gray area.

"We are not trying to get something for nothing, nor are we asking for subsidies, protectionist policies, or other forms of support. We just want a long-term stable framework that allows everyone to conduct business responsibly. In my view, this is a perfectly natural request on many levels."——Marc Andreessen

Guidance issued by regulatory agencies can fill some gaps but cannot replace legislation. Changes in agency leadership or a new administration taking office can cause this guidance to change. When companies decide whether to invest in a business that takes five or even ten years to yield results, they must know what the rules are, which regulatory agency has jurisdiction, and whether products developed today will remain legal tomorrow.

The CLARITY Act will provide a long-term framework for businesses to operate responsibly.

How Will the CLARITY Act Protect Consumers?

The most basic consumer protection issue in the current crypto market is that crypto trading platforms are not subject to a complete federal system, whereas major securities and commodities trading venues such as the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq have long been under such regulation.

The New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq have clear federal regulatory agencies. In contrast, crypto trading platforms lack registration, supervision, audit, information disclosure, trading monitoring, and customer asset protection systems covering the entire market. The CLARITY Act will provide a clear path for digital assets to transfer from SEC regulation to CFTC regulation.

Crypto trading platforms registered at the federal level will be subject to audit and financial control requirements. Platforms must safely custody customer assets, comply with anti-fraud and insider trading prohibitions, and provide operational information to regulators. Companies that refuse to meet these standards will not be able to operate legally in the United States.

These requirements help prevent scenarios that caused the FTX collapse from happening again. It was alleged that FTX transferred funds between affiliated entities, had insufficient internal controls, and the customer assets actually held did not match the amounts claimed. Federal regulation cannot guarantee that fraud will never occur, but it can significantly increase the difficulty of concealing fraud and allow regulators to intervene before problems turn into disasters.

"There must be a system first. Enterprises must have risk control, comply with regulations, and undergo audits... We also need it to prevent disasters from happening and avoid more FTXs."——Marc Andreessen

The same principles apply to products sold under the name "stablecoins." Terra-Luna was once promoted as a stable asset, but it had neither U.S. dollar reserves nor other stable reserve asset support. Under the stablecoin regulatory framework, compliant U.S. dollar stablecoins must be fully backed by corresponding reserves and audited. The CLARITY Act will bring similar constraints to other parts of the crypto market.

How Does the CLARITY Act Prevent Regulatory Ambiguity from Rewarding Violators?

Ambiguous regulatory rules can trigger a race to the bottom.

A U.S. company that takes compliance seriously may need to invest significant funds in lawyers, internal controls, audits, sanctions screening, and customer protection. These tasks are costly and may slow down product development. Offshore competitors can save on these expenses, replicate products, provide services at lower prices, and move faster, with their speed coming precisely from not doing compliance.

The result is that uncertainty penalizes responsible enterprises while benefiting offshore competitors. Law-abiding U.S. trading platforms bear all compliance costs, while non-compliant offshore platforms continue to provide services to U.S. users when they should not.

"Currently, which rules apply to which institutions is extremely unclear. I recognize that as long as there are gray areas in regulation, the market will basically move towards a race to the bottom... This ambiguity ultimately allows bad actors to take advantage."——Chris Dixon

The CLARITY Act will draw regulatory boundaries: which enterprises belong to intermediaries, which rules apply to them, which agency regulates them, and what the consequences of refusing compliance will be. Any company that custodies customer funds or assists in completing financial transactions must comply with the same types of anti-money laundering, sanctions, and Treasury regulations as similar financial institutions such as payment service providers and fintech companies.

Clear rules benefit enterprises willing to meet standards; gray areas benefit those looking for loopholes.

How Will the CLARITY Act Strengthen Sanctions Enforcement?

Privacy does not equal anonymity. People often describe public blockchains as anonymous systems, but in actual use, many public chains are highly transparent.

Transactions are permanently recorded on public ledgers. Wallet addresses do not directly display legal names, but investigators can track fund flows and link these activities to trading platforms, accounts, devices, or other identity information. Years later, the records still exist; therefore, law enforcement agencies may find evidence from them that was not available when the transactions occurred.

Some payment methods do not leave public traces, but blockchains leave traceable paths. For this reason, some national security officials describe crypto transactions as "leaving traces for future prosecution": records left today may help investigators identify and prosecute criminals in the future.

"It applies the same anti-money laundering and Treasury rules applicable to other market intermediaries to crypto intermediaries."——Chris Dixon

But traceability and privacy are two different issues. One should not be forced to disclose every medical expense or transfer to the world just to use a blockchain. The existing financial system also recognizes that ordinary people need privacy, while regulated institutions must still fulfill sanctions and anti-money laundering obligations.

Early debates surrounding internet encryption technology provide a useful reference. Strong encryption technology was once seen as a threat because criminals could also use it; in export controls, it was even classified alongside military technology. But it is precisely encryption technology that made secure banking, e-commerce, and confidential communication possible.

"Just because bad actors use encryption technology to do bad things, does that make encryption bad? Or is encryption the foundation for building trust, conducting business, and allowing law-abiding citizens at home and abroad to cooperate and do business with each other, making it valuable in itself?"——Marc Andreessen

Blockchain privacy faces the same line. Privacy protects legal activities; concealment aimed at evading the law is still subject to law enforcement pursuit.

How Does the CLARITY Act Address Stablecoin Reward Controversies While Allowing Banks to Continue Developing On-Chain Businesses?

Banks believe that stablecoin issuers and wallet service providers should not rebuild deposit accounts in disguise outside the banking system by paying interest on balances. They worry that consumers may transfer deposits from banks into stablecoin products, thereby reducing the source of funds banks use to issue loans.

The CLARITY Act addresses this concern: the bill prohibits paying interest on stablecoin balances and also prohibits products that are equivalent to interest-bearing accounts in function or economic effect.

However, the bill still allows rewards based on transaction behavior. Wallet service providers or retailers can reward customers who use stablecoins for shopping, just as credit cards offer points and retailers operate membership reward programs. The difference between the two is: the former receives rewards due to consumption behavior, while the latter collects interest merely by holding a balance.

This compromise basically meets the main demands of banks, while not going so far as to ban ordinary reward programs. Many reward programs currently offered by card networks, payment apps, and retailers also adopt similar models.

It is worth noting that the banks making these demands are themselves adopting blockchain technology. Large financial institutions such as Goldman Sachs, Fidelity, BlackRock, Stripe, Wells Fargo, and JPMorgan Chase have all developed or supported blockchain products.

"One change blockchain brings to the financial industry is providing a unified framework that allows everyone to say: 'Okay, let's enter the 21st century together.' So, it solves not only technical problems but also coordination problems."——Chris Dixon

Banks see the same opportunities as the crypto industry: existing financial infrastructure is fragmented and difficult to transform. Blockchain provides a shared framework that allows financial institutions to reduce intermediary layers, settle assets on common infrastructure, and collaboratively advance modernization, without requiring each bank to separately rebuild a system connected to each other.

Under What Circumstances Do Software Developers Need to Bear Responsibility?

The CLARITY Act distinguishes between two types of behavior: knowingly helping others commit crimes, and publishing general-purpose software. Developers who develop tools for criminal purposes, market tools to criminals, or directly assist illegal activities will still bear responsibility.

What the bill does not accept is another practice: making developers bear unlimited liability for all downstream uses that are unforeseeable and uncontrollable. Open-source code can be copied, modified, and deployed by people the developer has never seen, used in scenarios the original author never envisioned. If developers are required to be responsible for all these uses, open-source software will be almost impossible to continue developing or obtain funding support.

"This is simply impossible, and it would make software development impossible, because no developer can predict how software will be used in the future. You don't even have to look at it from a software perspective; it's the same for any product. If I run a hotel, and a criminal checks in and plans a crime in the hotel, does that make me an accomplice?"——Marc Andreessen

Its impact is not limited to the crypto industry. Academic research, startups, venture capital, and open AI models all rely on open-source software. A feasible liability boundary should be subjective intent and actual participation: when a person knowingly assists in a crime, they should be held accountable; if neutral tools are abused by others later, it cannot automatically make the tool developers bear responsibility.

How Exactly Will the CLARITY Act Handle Securities Law?

A security does not automatically become a non-security just because it is put on a blockchain. Tokenized stocks are still stocks, also still belong to securities, and continue to be regulated by the SEC. Enterprises cannot evade information disclosure, registration, and investor protection requirements just by moving assets on-chain or calling them "tokens."

"What the CLARITY Act does is just write this into law and provide clear definitions. This way, everyone can know exactly where they stand without having to file a lawsuit every time to find the answer."——Chris Dixon

What the bill aims to solve is another issue: how to regulate digital assets related to blockchain networks whose nature changes as the network develops.

Briefly, the CLARITY Act establishes a risk-based framework. A new blockchain network usually starts with a centralized entity: founders, companies, or small teams may control the network, possess information unknown to the public, and make decisions that affect token value. At this stage, related assets will be regulated by the SEC, subject to requirements similar to securities, including information disclosure, insider restrictions, and lock-up periods for founders and early investors.

As the network develops, control may gradually decentralize. If the network reaches the decentralization threshold specified in the bill, the nature of related assets may be closer to commodities rather than corporate securities. At this point, regulatory responsibility will transfer to the CFTC.

This does not mean the asset is unregulated from then on. Commodity regulation also deals with abuse behaviors such as fraud, market manipulation, and cornering the market. The regulatory agency changes because the nature of the asset itself has changed.

The bill will also introduce some restrictions that are not currently clearly defined. While the network is still controlled by a centralized entity, founders, venture capital firms, and other insiders may face longer lock-up periods and stricter information disclosure obligations. These restrictions aim to prevent insiders from dumping assets on the market before ordinary participants have obtained the same information, or before the product has developed into a sufficiently decentralized network.

What Happens If the CLARITY Act Fails to Pass?

Crypto regulation will not disappear because of this. Agencies such as the SEC, CFTC, and the U.S. Treasury have been issuing regulatory guidance and using existing authority to formulate rules within their respective jurisdictions; if the bill does not pass, they will most likely continue to do so.

The problem is that after a change in administration, regulatory agencies' interpretation of the law may change accordingly. Companies may invest years developing products based on one set of expectations, only to suddenly face a completely different interpretation after an election or change in agency leadership.

This uncertainty affects not only investment but also consumer protection. A long-term framework can clarify the powers of regulatory agencies, while requiring enterprises to complete registration, disclose information, protect customer assets, and comply with market rules. Without legislation, these responsibilities will remain scattered across different systems and may trigger disputes at any time.

"If the rules underfoot are constantly changing, enterprises are naturally less willing to invest significant time and money into development."——Chris Dixon

This industry has already experienced years of tough enforcement and political hostility; the more likely result is not the disappearance of the industry, but enterprises continuing to shift development to other regions. In this way, the supervision the U.S. can implement will instead decrease. U.S. regulatory agencies will find it harder to supervise offshore enterprises, law enforcement agencies will find it harder to reach these companies; their willingness to build products around U.S. standards will also be lower.

Why Does the CLARITY Act Continue the Tradition of U.S. Technological Leadership?

Once a technology is invented, it usually does not disappear. The real question is: where will it develop, which companies will become the leaders, and whose rules will shape it.

For more than a century, the United States has benefited from the advantage of major technologies being born and developing within the country. Technological leadership brings enterprises, employment, tax revenue, and professional capabilities, also providing economic resources for national key affairs and bringing security advantages.

"Regardless of political stance, every U.S. citizen should hope that the United States becomes the global technology leader."——Marc Andreessen

The history of encryption technology development illustrates the stakes involved. When the United States restricted the export of strong encryption technology, foreign competitors did not stop development, but placed products outside the United States, and users turned to use these products. Only after restrictions were adjusted could U.S. companies participate in building a secure internet economy.

Blockchain technology brings the same issue. Future financial systems, technical standards, and leading enterprises will emerge somewhere. If they develop mainly overseas, the United States will lose both economic opportunities and regulatory influence.

The CLARITY Act will give responsible enterprises a reason to build according to U.S. law. a16z believes this will benefit consumers, law enforcement, and national security, and also help the United States participate in setting standards for the next generation of financial infrastructure.

Which Other Institutions Support the CLARITY Act?

Supporters of the CLARITY Act include legislators, law enforcement organizations, financial institutions, and technology companies.

This legislation is the result of years of promotion by both parties in the U.S. Congress. Legislators from both parties have been working hard to establish a federal framework for the digital asset market. The largest law enforcement organization in the United States, the Fraternal Order of Police (Fraternal Order of Police), has also expressed support for the bill and refuted the claim that "the bill will weaken sanctions or anti-money laundering enforcement."

"The Fraternal Order of Police just announced support for the CLARITY Act. It is the largest law enforcement organization in the United States."——Chris Dixon

Support also comes from the financial industry. Goldman Sachs CEO David Solomon has already endorsed the CLARITY Act, and other financial institutions and fintech companies are already developing blockchain products. a16z believes that support from different fields indicates that all parties are gradually forming a consensus: the United States needs a set of clear, enforceable digital asset market rules.

When market rules are vague, consumers cannot determine what protections they enjoy; responsible enterprises must bear high compliance costs, while offshore competitors can bypass these requirements. The CLARITY Act attempts to replace this state of uncertainty with a clear system.

What really needs to be compared is not the CLARITY Act with another hypothetical law, but the system after the bill passes versus the current state. a16z believes that as long as a clear development path is provided for responsible enterprises, the bill can strengthen consumer protection, support law enforcement, and increase the possibility of next-generation financial technology developing in the United States.