
Ethereum Upgrade Tests Expose Hidden Risks: Transactions Show as Successful, But Payments May Fail
Author: TechFlow
On November 17, according to the disclosed progress of the proposed Glamsterdam upgrade testing by the official Ethereum network, smart contracts revealed compatibility vulnerabilities. Simulations by developers targeting the Juicebox protocol's payment contract showed that on the Sepolia testnet, although some transactions executed successfully, internal payments might fail.
This leads to fund allocation or fee payments being silently skipped. The issue stems from adjustments to the underlying execution billing logic in the upgrade proposal, causing existing contracts that rely on traditional exception handling to experience unexpected forks. The Ethereum Foundation has placed this item on the agenda for its testing meetings, scheduling a review of countermeasures on November 19.

Live Testing on Sepolia Reveals Fund Withholding and Fee Waivers
According to live tests documented in the official Juicebox technical documentation, the anomaly manifests as successful outer transaction confirmation, but incomplete sub-call fund transfers. In NFT purchase tests, even when internal operations to pay affiliated projects failed due to out-of-gas, buyers still received the NFTs, with unpaid funds lingering in the payment project.
In token distribution tests, system-reserved token allocation operations completed normally, but cross-project payment processes were interrupted. This execution deviation caused beneficiaries to actually receive the project's original tokens rather than the cross-project payment settlement results originally set by the contract, directly altering the final flow of on-chain fund distribution.
Cash redemption tests further exposed the risk of fee mechanism failure. Within the gas range listed in the report (679,622 to 817,622 gas), users could normally complete cash redemptions, but the internal 2.5% protocol fee that should have been paid was not executed, effectively waiving the user's fee burden entirely.
State Write Cost Increases Combined with Catch Mechanisms Trigger Silent Failures
Juicebox developer mejango pointed out that the issue relates to step changes in opcode gas consumption and contract error handling mechanisms. Under the testing rules, the core corresponds to the EIP-8037 proposal, which significantly increases the gas costs for state creation and new storage writes.
With the substantial increase in new storage write costs, sub-calls involving internal payments in transactions would exhaust their gas limits and fail earlier than the outer logic. Normally, a sub-call failure propagating upward would trigger a transaction rollback, but developers widely used try/catch exception handling structures to process internal calls, isolating the errors.
When an internal payment is halted due to insufficient gas, the try/catch block captures the error and prevents the exception from bubbling up, allowing the outer transaction to continue executing and be confirmed. For comparison, in similar simulations conducted by developers on the mainnet, the exact same gas range only resulted in complete transaction failure or fully executed payments, with never any observed internal skips.
Risk Management for Legacy Contracts and Foundation Review Milestones
This discrepancy between the mainnet and testnet reveals the profound impact of underlying gas pricing adjustments on historically deployed contracts. The gas reservations and exception handling mechanisms of numerous non-upgradeable smart contracts were designed based on legacy models; the increased write costs instead transformed the previously fault-tolerant catching logic into a hidden risk for fund leakage.
External audits and independent agencies investigating legacy contracts have become an industry consensus. Facing the compatibility challenges exposed by testing, the Ethereum core development team has initiated a special assessment. The Ethereum Foundation has added the Juicebox report and PoC materials to the agenda for key personnel responsible for the EIP-8038 proposal and others to compare against.
According to the public governance schedule, the Ethereum Foundation has arranged a special meeting on November 19 to further discuss the specific scope of impacts found during testing and subsequent response measures. To date, officials have not yet made a final decision regarding modifying proposal parameters, and the team continues to track security validations at state write boundaries.














