
Liquid Staking and Yield Vaults: Why Are They Difficult to Sustain on Hyperliquid?
Author: DevenMat
Translated by: AididiaoJP, Foresight News
DeFi primitives on HyperEVM are entering into a structural conflict with the market structure of HyperCore. Primitives such as lending markets, tokenized vaults, and LSTs are difficult to replicate on Hyperliquid in their traditional form.
The core thesis is that portfolio margin is making circular lending against Hyperliquid-native assets unviable, while the vast majority of current DeFi primitives rely on circular lending. Consequently, DeFi on Hyperliquid is positioned in competition with HyperCore's growth.
There are two corresponding solution paths: first, build DeFi markets rooted in token utility rather than relying on the old paradigm of recycled yields; second, the DeFi layer must complement HyperCore's growth, or it will be absorbed or phased out.
I. An Economy Built on Yield Leverage
The backbone of traditional DeFi is realized through the recycling of on-chain native yield sources: native yields, homogeneous lending against those yield-bearing receipts, and downstream DeFi flywheels. This structure underpins most DeFi activity.
Two fundamental shifts have occurred in the DeFi market structure on Hyperliquid.
Portfolio Margin
Portfolio margin is Hyperliquid's native margin engine. All liquidity previously dedicated to leveraged yield is siphoned off to serve leveraged trading.
This mechanism was not designed for homogeneous lending, altering the conditions upon which traditional DeFi flywheels operate and leaving a lack of direct alternatives:
- Lack of rehypothecatable liquidity available for recycling. When borrowing USDC against HYPE collateral on AAVE, that HYPE collateral can be reused by stHYPE/kHYPE recyclers, lowering circular lending costs. When borrowing USDC against HYPE on HyperCore, this portion of HYPE liquidity is not made available for recycling.
- Does not support lower-capital-consuming liquidation paths like those in EVM lending markets. It is designed around orderbook liquidation. Using interest-bearing derivatives as collateral would require establishing a separate deep orderbook on HyperCore; whereas on AAVE and Morpho, interest-bearing derivatives are supported via mechanisms like withdrawal queue liquidations.
How AAVE's Growth Strategy Differs from Portfolio Margin
AAVE subsidizes ETH lending by onboarding significant whale ETH-USDC lending activity, and uses E-Mode to provide special liquidation paths for interest-bearing derivatives, enhancing stETH's usability as collateral. Of the supplied WETH, 80.6% belongs to accounts using it to borrow stablecoins. AAVE's pool engine creates a flywheel between USDC margin and ETH yield leverage, cross-subsidizing both sides through symbiotic relationships.
Portfolio margin, conversely, withdraws USDC margin from the pool system without re-lending collateral or permitting homogeneous lending. Circular trading is thereby killed off without replacement. If USDC lending migrates from a pool-based model to portfolio margin, cycling Hyperliquid-native yields—including vault tokens, LP positions, and LSTs—would be removed from the DeFi economy. Yet the entire current DeFi economy relies on this transaction, as well as the symbiotic relationship between margin and circularity.
II. The Limited Structural Role of Staking Emissions on Hyperliquid
Hyperliquid's uniqueness lies in the fact that the chain is already sufficiently useful, eliminating the need to drive consensus participation through network-level inflation. Staking emissions play a limited marginal role on Hyperliquid; whereas on most chains, they serve as the native yield source sustaining the majority of DeFi activity.
- Staking emissions play a minimal role in aligning holders. Net new demand for HYPE stems from HIP-3, HIP-4, AQA, and staking tier discounts, not from the 2.2% yield.
- The validator set actually consists of custodians, DATs, data providers, and organizations running validators for operational purposes and latency reasons, rather than for yield. The number of 0% commission validators shows that entry into the active set is a privilege many are willing to pay for.
If staking emissions offer no significant benefit to Hyperliquid, they should be reassessed. DeFi on Hyperliquid also needs to quickly redefine its purpose.
III. Current State of Hyperliquid DeFi: Liquidity Is Being Siphoned
HyperEVM DeFi is fundamentally driven by LST leverage, and the current situation is not optimistic.
Portfolio Margin Is Siphoning Liquidity
On September 18, Hyperliquid announced manual lending functionality: borrowing USDC against HYPE or BTC collateral on HyperCore.
Two days later, an account on HyperLend withdrew 743,058 HYPE, bridged it to HyperCore, used it as collateral to borrow $25.65 million in USDC, and repaid $25.6 million in HyperLend loans. The entire HyperEVM borrowing position migrated to HyperCore within 33 minutes.
A second account followed suit. HyperLend's HYPE utilization rate jumped from 78% to 98%, and the HYPE borrow rate surged from 1% to 90%. Circular trading became unprofitable.
Structurally, portfolio margin moves HYPE liquidity from HyperEVM to HyperCore. Without intervention, this process could continue until liquidity is drained.
As a result, LSTs on Hyperliquid structurally struggle to support their own economies, experiencing prolonged depegs over time. This structural fragility is observable in how kHYPE has experienced more frequent and severe depeg events compared to similar ecosystem LSTs on Ethereum and Solana.
Liquid staking is inherently a capital-intensive tool by design: it requires HYPE lenders to service low-interest, stable circular flows; it relies on DEX liquidity and arbitrageurs to maintain pegs and reduce exit costs. When the native margin engine extracts the system's core components, the flywheel becomes unsustainable.
Survival Paths
Valantis's strategy has consistently been to optimize the DeFi economy under capital constraints: stHYPE's native dynamic instant redemption buffer reduces reliance on deep DEX liquidity, enabling users to exit within seven days; STEX recycles liquidity among HYPE lenders, servicing circular flows while providing swap liquidity when needed. Despite being only one-fifth the size of kHYPE, stHYPE maintains a more stable peg. Nevertheless, market pressure remains evident. The staking yield trade is now too fragile to assume the flywheel can withstand portfolio margin. Absorbing all liquidity toward HyperCore is the natural trend under the current structure.
Kinetiq claims to have built the fastest-growing LST in its category, positioning itself as the Lido and Jito of Hyperliquid. However, neither Ethereum nor Solana has a native margin engine competing directly with lending markets. Structurally speaking, Hyperliquid is one of the least suitable environments in crypto for operating standard LSTs.
Without this trade, standard LSTs lack viable use cases. The disappearance of usable liquidity for interest-bearing derivatives must be understood in context: today, the majority of DeFi consists of interest-bearing derivatives—tokenized yield vaults, LP positions, and LSTs. The loss of circular liquidity means most historically proven DeFi primitives face obsolescence. Therefore, new primitives must be built.
IV. The Objective of HYPE Staking Is Not Yield
Most DeFi on Ethereum lives downstream of the LST leverage cycle, treating circularity as a first-class citizen. But Hyperliquid locks up HYPE through a different mechanism: instead of paying holders to stake, it requires every entity wishing to utilize exchange resources to buy and stake the token.
- Deploy perpetual markets under HIP-3, or outcome markets under HIP-4: stake 500,000 HYPE, locked for six months, subject to slashing.
- Enable stablecoins as aligned quote assets: stake 1,000,000 HYPE.
- Trade at reduced fees: stake 10 HYPE for a 5% discount, scaling up to a 40% discount at the maximum 500,000 HYPE tier. Intermediate tiers exist at 100, 1,000, 10,000, and 100,000 HYPE. Top traders and market makers lock HYPE to access lower fee tiers, saving over $40 million annually.
- Peer directly with foundation nodes for low-latency data: stake 10,000 HYPE.
Each of the above represents partners or traders consuming network resources and paying for them with locked HYPE. To consume network resources, staking HYPE is the key to access. Liquid staking should build markets around this access key.
- Act I: Yield derived from high economic security costs—stETH;
- Act II: Yield derived from privileges over liquidity routing—JitoSOL;
- Act III: Yield derived from direct access to liquidity—Staked HYPE.
This is not about tokenizing HYPE's native yield, but rather building an economy around its gated access to network resources and liquidity.
V. DeFi Primitives Serving the Core Market Structure
The primitives that will survive here are those that can bring HYPE utility to areas the Core cannot cover on its own.
Native Staking Cannot Serve as Collateral for Portfolio Margin
Traders wanting to use their own HYPE as margin are forgoing yield and reduced Hyperliquid fees. Portfolio margin cannot accept staked HYPE as collateral. The margin engine requires liquidators—either an orderbook or a risk-curated lending market willing to take on redemption risk; staked native HYPE provides neither. Portfolio margin is fundamentally incompatible with native staking. LSTs are required to bring staking benefits into the margin framework.
An LST that can carry trading fee discounts could solve this. The logic is straightforward: stHYPE tokenizes the discount, which cannot be replicated without a liquidity receipt, thereby spawning downstream DeFi activity. This forms a Hyperliquid-native DeFi flywheel.
HyperCore Handles USDC Margin, HyperEVM Manages Derivative Risk
HyperCore's portfolio margin does not support derivative assets operating in a capital-efficient manner. Cold-starting separate orderbooks for stETH-USDC and stHYPE-USDC is capital-intensive and would compete with HyperCore's own ETH-USDC and HYPE-USDC orderbooks.
One path forward: HyperEVM margin absorbs derivative risk, while HyperCore absorbs price risk.
- AAVE: stHYPE → HYPE
- HyperCore: HYPE → USDC
This model minimizes competition with HyperCore, as it merely fills gaps while still utilizing HyperCore's USDC liquidity. HyperCore does not absorb derivative risk; the EVM handles that segment. The core challenge lies in keeping HYPE borrow rates low given that most HYPE-USDC lending has migrated to HyperCore. If this issue is resolved, circularity could regain vitality across a suite of new DeFi assets empowered by Hyperliquid's unique traits.
VI. Markets for HYPE Utility and Specialized Yield
At the core of tokenization is creating new markets by splitting assets. Valantis's integration with Pendle achieves this: tokenizing Hyperliquid fee discounts.
Traders pay a premium to purchase fee discounts from HYPE holders. stHYPE holders realize value by selling staking tier discounts to YT holders and capturing a premium, reflected in PT yields.
This uses DeFi to generate new yield sources and their associated markets, centered around HYPE's asset utility. Similar structures could emerge around HIP-3, HIP-4, and future HYPE utility use cases.
Specialized Yield Driven by DeFi
Staking is not homogeneous. The same 500,000 staked HYPE holds different value to different participants: a 2.2% yield for passive holders; a 40% discount on taker fees for market-making desks; a license to operate perpetual exchanges for deployers; rights to launch outcome markets for another participant; and distribution channels to crypto's fastest-growing exchange for stablecoin issuers.
Underneath identical staking positions lie distinct businesses, almost all acquired through OTC trades, each with its own yield profile, lockup periods, and slashing terms. This is specialized yield on Hyperliquid. It does not originate from on-chain emissions, but from what staking unlocks for specific counterparties.
As staking becomes non-homogeneous, primitives such as restaking and stacking may become tools to deliver value that HyperCore cannot replicate on its own. Hyperliquid's staking utility dynamics open new spaces for DeFi design principles.
Between December and August, stHYPE delegated HYPE to Ethena's HyENA exchange, generating over $1 million in HYPE rewards for stHYPE holders. This transformed a private, illiquid yield source into a publicly accessible one, allowing over $100 million in HYPE to enter and exit without delay. This new yield created fresh economics for the stHYPE economy, permeating lending markets, AMMs, and retail wallets.
The next phase for stHYPE will rebuild this state at scale and with network effects. This DeFi structure stands to accelerate HyperCore's growth rather than oppose it. DeFi liquidity may ultimately bring more markets to HyperCore than private counterparties.
VII. Why Build Here?
Any Hyperliquid project built on the assumption of a "generic DeFi layer" faces greater exposure than it likely realizes.
Neither speed nor composability is holding back HyperEVM; the root issue lies in market structure. New sidecars or L2s will not automatically fix this.
HyperEVM is facing challenges because outdated mental models no longer apply. The DeFi playbook inherited by Hyperliquid has concluded, and the next iteration of its DeFi layer is taking shape.














